The new Steven Spielberg film Disclosure Day, see: https://hpanwo-tv.blogspot.com/2026/06/disclosure-day-film-review.html,
has been criticized for ending too abruptly. I think enough people have seen it
now to make spoilers fairly redundant. In the final scene the heroes battle the
villains to take control of a TV studio. The heroes win and broadcast an array
of classified UFO videos on the global networks, and even invite a real alien
in front of the camera; an act of "catastrophic Disclosure". We are
shown many shots of people standing still in silence watching the broadcast.
Then we see Margaret, the heroine, sitting in front on the TV cameras as newsreader
and she simply says: "Listen." What happens next?... Nothing, the
playback simply cuts to the credits. Nothing happens next; that's the end of
the film. To begin with I agreed with the people who said that this finale is a
bit too truncated and sudden. There should have been some kind of epilogue
scene in which we see the results of Disclosure on the world at large. However,
over time and with reflection, and a couple more viewings on the movie now I
have it on home media, see: https://hpanwo-voice.blogspot.com/2026/09/disclosure-day-dvd.html,
I've changed my mind. I think that moment was the right moment to end the
story. The reason I think so is because of an article I wrote a while ago. It's
to do with something said by the British author China MiƩville, that it is not
possible to produce a credible and inventive fictional portrayal of a social
order on the other side of some catalyzing and revolutionary transformation.
The Legacy Prorgramme has us so hypnotized and institutionalized that we cannot
think beyond it and any attempt to do so will inevitably fail and produce
something domesticated, banal, trite and dull, see: https://hpanwo-bb.blogspot.com/2023/12/piw-in-fiction.html.
I find myself agreeing with China
and this is why I think Spielberg and Koepp did the right thing in terminating
the narrative at that point.
That forces me to confront an uncomfortable question: What
about Redeemed? The third instalment
of the Roswell trilogy, Roswell Redeemed- Humanity After Disclosure,
see: https://hpanwo-bb.blogspot.com/2018/12/roswell-redeemed-is-here.html.
I won't give you any spoilers, but the three books can be summarized thus: Rising, fake Disclosure; Revealed, real Disclosure, Redeemed, what happens afterwards? The
title gives it away, actually. I've come to see the final book as lesser
compared to the first and second. I don't think Brendan Quilley is as deep and
complex a character as Siobhan and Clane. He doesn't develop and contemplate in
the way his sister and father do. I've come to see him mostly as a pair of eyes
and a mouth for myself in the story; not a character, but a medium for me to
tell it. That is a bad way to write and on reflection it has left me
unsatisfied with the character and therefore the novel. Perhaps that is because
it is set specifically in a post-Disclosure world, a world that I cannot
properly envisage because it has not yet happened. I know not everybody will
agree. I know many people, especially fellow authors, will cringe at that and
accuse me of surrender, making excuses, or even intellectual cowardice. I don't
think so. I have come to the conclusion that maybe I should not have written Roswell Redeemed. The conclusive scene,
"returning to their roots", at the end could have been fitted into
the ending of Revealed. Despite this,
I will not be altering what I have published. Redeemed will remain on the press in its current edition. I do
think the final book does have other elements that I like and have value. There
is no going back for a writer. Whether I am right or wrong will be judged by
history. It is only in the post-Disclosure real world that we will be able to
compare my imaginary picture to what that world is really like. I've a feeling
we won't have to wait much longer.
See here for more information: https://hpanwo.blogspot.com/2020/02/ufo-disclosure-portal.html.
And: https://hpanwo-tv.blogspot.com/2023/01/ben-emlyn-jones-live-at-truth-seekers.html.
See here for more information: https://hpanwo.blogspot.com/2020/02/ufo-disclosure-portal.html.
And: https://hpanwo-tv.blogspot.com/2023/01/ben-emlyn-jones-live-at-truth-seekers.html.









